why I’m giving up on meeting one to one

Your standard one to one meeting

Meeting with people one to one — to chat about life, pray and read the Bible with the aim of growing as disciples of Jesus — is one of the more stable features the kind of university (aka ‘college’) student ministry I serve in.

But it’s become increasingly clear to me that I need to give it up.

Huh? Give up meeting one to one? What am I smoking?

Let me explain how I reached this conclusion.

To start with, there have been some pragmatic factors pushing me in this direction.

In particular, I’ve only been on campus two days/week for the second half of this year. But I’d already begun meeting with a bunch of students — some currently in leadership, some potential leaders, and some in particular need of pastoral care.

I didn’t want to stop meeting with any more of these people than I had to. But my time and resources were limited.

So I decided to try combining my one to ones into triplets.

After only one semester of trying it, the results are far from conclusive. But tentatively I can report that…

  1. I was able to keep regularly meeting up with almost all of the students I had been meeting with in first semester.
  2. I was forced to act on my conviction that ministry is as much caught as taught (instead of simply telling the student leaders to disciple someone else, I was able to work with them to do it).
  3. I am starting to re-examine the rationale for my pre-existing preference to do discipleship one to one.

I’ve barely even begun thinking through the third point. But I’ve been stimulated by a chapter from Transforming Discipleship by Greg Ogden, which someone recently pushed my way.

Ogden argues very strongly against our tendency to model discipling on the Paul-Timothy relationship. To his mind, this brings with it an unhelpfully asymmetrical expert-learner dynamic — something like which is perhaps encoded in the language of ‘investing in someone’ that I typically reach for to describe these meetings.

I’m not sure I’m entirely with him.

Theologically, I am drawn to the idea that we serve one another out of our shared weakness and interdependence (rather than me serving you out of my strength and independence).

The most deeply Christian way to serve is to help each other love and trust Jesus more. And anything that helps us actually live this has got to be a good thing.

But the New Testament does seem to grant the possibility that individuals will make an asymmetrical contribution to others — even if it also always recognises a degree of reciprocity. (I’m thinking here of passages like Romans 1.8-15.)

Equally, I don’t buy that switching to triplets will automatically address the more toxic aspects of this dynamic. A tendency to see yourself as God’s gift to another person (in a bad way) won’t necessarily be mitigated by adding an in extra person.

I am, however, inclined to agree that our theological rationale for privileging one to one as the context for discipleship is inadequate.

Or maybe I’ve just inadequately understood and digested it?

Advertisements

6 comments

  1. Fascinating thoughts. I’m not sold yet – mostly because of how helpful I’ve found one-to-ones personally (as a student) and now as an element of ministry on a campus.

    I wonder if there’s space for both. Training students to disciple well by inviting them to do it with you, while also maintaining some regular one-to-one relationships as well, as needs dictate.

  2. I’m guessing that our our “theological rationale for privileging one to one as the context for discipleship” is not really all that theological. I suspect that our natural preference for the “Paul-Timothy” relationship is because of our individualism more than anything: the individual is the basic unit for us, so the “Paul-Timothy” relationship is always going to seem better than anything more corporate/collective/group-based.

    But I figure that there’s more to Paul’s relationship with Timothy than we think. For one thing, Paul and Timothy served together in teams. For another, am I right in saying that Paul’s letters to Timothy were not “personal correspondence”? I.e. they are, like the rest of the NT letters, designed originally to be read aloud in the gathering (?). In any event, the idea that Paul’s “one-on-one” relationship with Timothy is ground zero is questionable.

  3. Hi Chris, it’s interesting to read your thoughts on this matter, thanks for sharing. I’ve also thought a bit about the issue of ‘having all the answers’ in a 1:1 setting and therefore the mentoree relying too heavily on you. One of my solutions has been to try and adopt more of a coach approach, this involves asking key questions to allow the student to come up with their own answers. I am reading a book called ‘The coach model’ by Keith Webb which is very interesting and insightful, I’d certainly recommend it!

  4. This year we had three home grown ministry apprentices from our smaller campus ministry [approx 30 at main meetings]. If I was asked what is the single most significant human factor that contributed to this I would say it was the one to one catch ups. I won’t be giving that up in a hurry. Yes it is a luxury that we may not always have but if we have the staff resources I believe we have good reason for investing in students this way. It has great impact, being able to focus fully on shaping the one person, addressing their questions is very valuable. Moreover, one to ones can transition into triplets after one year but may not necessarily function well at the start of the year. Furthermore, it’s not a ministry that can be done outside uni very well. The university years are a window of opportunity to take a student and enthuse them for serving Christ. Why would we want to give that up?

  5. Pingback: Kurt's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s